This week’s pairing in our city-by-city series covers two cities that share a name but not much else: Laguna Beach and Laguna Hills. One is a coastal resort town with some of the highest rents in the county. The other is an inland, suburban community with rents closer to the Orange County middle. Looking at the Laguna Beach Laguna Hills rental market side by side shows how much location drives rent.

Laguna Beach: premium rents, wide data gaps
Laguna Beach is a small, coastal market, and published rent figures vary widely depending on the source and on which properties are included. Rentometer’s May 2026 data puts the average one-bedroom at about $3,538 across all property types, and about $3,407 for apartments, with two-bedrooms in a much higher range. Apartments.com’s March 2026 figures run lower, near $3,000 for a one-bedroom and $3,545 for a two-bedroom, while Trulia lists one-bedrooms near $4,000.
Taken together, a one-bedroom in Laguna Beach generally falls somewhere in the $3,000 to $4,000 range, and two-bedrooms vary far more, from about $3,500 to well over $5,000 depending on the source. That spread comes from a market with limited apartment inventory and many single-family homes and condos, where location (ocean views, walkability to downtown, proximity to the beach) and unit type can change the rent by thousands of dollars a month.
We couldn’t find a reliable Laguna Beach vacancy rate, so we’re not quoting one. For owners, the practical takeaway is that averages tell you very little here. Comparables for your specific property type and street matter far more.
Laguna Hills: mid-range and more consistent
Laguna Hills is more straightforward. RentCafe’s May 2026 data shows an average apartment rent of about $2,857, with one-bedrooms around $2,623 and two-bedrooms around $3,074. Apartments.com shows similar numbers: about $2,509 for a one-bedroom and $3,199 for a two-bedroom in May. Rentometer’s January figures are close as well, at roughly $2,523 and $3,141.
Those sources land within about $100 to $200 of each other, which is a good sign that the range is reliable. A one-bedroom typically falls between $2,450 and $2,650 and a two-bedroom between $3,070 and $3,200. One source lists a vacancy rate of 8%, but it’s undated and we couldn’t confirm it, so we’d treat it with caution and look to your own local data instead.
What this means if you own in either market
The two cities call for different approaches. In Laguna Beach, with its premium and widely varied rents, pricing depends on getting the details right: the specific location, the condition, and what comparable properties are actually leasing for. An average is a starting point, not a price. In Laguna Hills, where the data lines up more cleanly, owners have a more predictable benchmark, and competitive pricing and well-kept units are what separate faster lease-ups from longer vacancies.
As in previous reports, the figures here come from published rental data sources, which differ in methodology (some include houses and condos, others mostly apartment communities), so treat them as directional. We weren’t able to find year-over-year trend figures for either city that we’d trust, so this report focuses on current levels.
Own a rental in Laguna Beach, Laguna Hills, or elsewhere in Orange County and want to know how your property compares to current market data? Reach out to Smart One Property Management.
Sources: Rentometer, Average Rent in Laguna Beach, CA; Apartments.com, Laguna Beach Rent Market Trends; RentCafe, Laguna Hills, CA Rental Market Trends; Apartments.com, Laguna Hills Rent Market Trends; Rentometer, Average Rent in Laguna Hills, CA.
